90 picks
Came up more than once
Picks that surfaced in at least two different conversations.
Bach
6 episodesThe most-mentioned composer of the year. Diarmaid MacCulloch on the chorale preludes, Jared Diamond working through all 200 cantatas at one a week, Terence Tao on the “very intricate patterns” that hooked him as a kid, and Tyler naming the B Minor Mass as what he’d pick from Christianity’s aesthetic legacy. Bach also comes up in passing with Arthur Brooks and Katja Hoyer.
From Diarmaid MacCulloch, Jared Diamond, Terence Tao, Luke Burgis, Arthur Brooks and Katja Hoyer
Shakespeare
6 episodesHenry Oliver and Tyler read Measure for Measure side by side, Tyler in the Folger edition and Oliver in the Arden, and Tyler names Orson Welles’s Chimes at Midnight the best Shakespeare film. Harvey Mansfield turns to Macbeth on ambition, Tyler asks Richard Hanania whether he’s come around on Shakespeare, Joanne Paul explains how the Tudors made him possible, and Cleopatra and Goethe bring him up with Toby Wilkinson and Katja Hoyer.
From Henry Oliver, Harvey Mansfield, Richard Hanania, Joanne Paul, Toby Wilkinson and Katja Hoyer
Latin American novels
3 episodesPaul Gillingham’s great Mexican novel is The Death of Artemio Cruz; Tyler counters with Pedro Páramo or The Savage Detectives. Luis Garicano loves García Márquez, Rulfo and Vargas Llosa, and Tyler brings up García Márquez again with Richard Hanania.
From Paul Gillingham, Luis Garicano and Richard Hanania
The Beatles
3 episodesBob Spitz is now writing about Lennon, and Tyler calls Mind Games and Rock ’n’ Roll “quite underrated” (Spitz: “You’re in a minority, Tyler”). Luis Garicano defends Let It Be, and “Hey Jude” comes up with Daron Acemoglu.
From Bob Spitz, Luis Garicano and Daron Acemoglu
Taylor Swift
3 episodesCraig Newmark has become a Swiftie, Bob Spitz would love to teach her more than “the four chords she knows,” and she’s Terence Tao’s comfort listening.
From Craig Newmark, Bob Spitz and Terence Tao
Shoot Out the Lights
3 episodesOne of Tyler’s favorite Bob Spitz books is his history of the 1969–70 Knicks. Tyler asks Chase Koch whether he was surprised by the Knicks winning the title this year, and asks Andrew Ross Sorkin about their chances.
From Bob Spitz, Chase Koch and Andrew Ross Sorkin
Atlas Shrugged
2 episodesHenry Oliver calls it “maybe the best genre novel ever written,” and Tyler finds the villains “remarkably true to current life.” Richard Hanania reads Conrad’s Nostromo as “Ayn Rand with less caffeine.”
From Henry Oliver and Richard Hanania
The Lord of the Rings
2 episodesTyler brings it up and Henry Oliver agrees: “clearly one of the great novels of the 20th century.” Terence Tao works to the film soundtrack.
From Henry Oliver and Terence Tao
Diarmaid MacCulloch’s books
2 episodesTyler recommends Lower Than the Angels: A History of Sex and Christianity “very highly” and says all his books are excellent. Annie Lowrey calls A History of Christianity “a very, very, very good book.”
From Diarmaid MacCulloch and Annie Lowrey
Vermeer: A Life Lost and Found
2 episodesAndrew Graham-Dixon’s “new and fascinating” book, which Annie Lowrey picked up after hearing the episode. He also recorded the audiobook himself.
From Andrew Graham-Dixon and Annie Lowrey
Thomas Mann
2 episodesTyler names him with Katja Hoyer as part of Germany’s great cultural legacy, and Luke Burgis weighs whether Mann or Dostoevsky better diagnoses modernity.
From Katja Hoyer and Luke Burgis
C. S. Lewis
2 episodesTyler finds something “unique and special and lasting” about him (Diarmaid MacCulloch is less sure), and Luke Burgis draws on his idea of dying “a series of small deaths to our ego.”
From Diarmaid MacCulloch and Luke Burgis
For the bird lover
2 episodesJared Diamond birds his own street in Los Angeles every weekend and says New Guinea is the world’s best birding, “no close second.” Craig Newmark feeds his pigeons “the good stuff.”
From Jared Diamond and Craig Newmark
Books
From this year’s guests
Mexico: A 500-Year History
Tyler: “the single best introduction to the history of Mexico.”
From Paul Gillingham
Surviving Rome: The Economic Lives of the 90%
Tyler says it has perhaps been his favorite economics book of the last year.
From Kim Bowes
Messy Jobs
Luis Garicano, Jin Li and Yanhui Wu. Tyler calls it “the best book on AI and the job market.”
From Luis Garicano
The Rolling Stones: The Biography
Bob Spitz’s latest, of which Tyler “read every page.”
From Bob Spitz
Ausländer: One Family’s Story of Escape and Exile
Michael Moritz’s family memoir, which Tyler says he would “absolutely recommend.”
From Michael Moritz
How Africa Works
Tyler: How Asia Works and How Africa Works are “essential reading.”
From Joe Studwell
Two Paths to Prosperity
Joel Mokyr, Avner Greif and Guido Tabellini. Tyler calls it “a wonderful new book.”
From Joel Mokyr
What Happened to Liberal Democracy?
Tyler: “a major work.”
From Daron Acemoglu
1873
From the author of Lords of Finance. Tyler: “new and wonderful.”
From Liaquat Ahamed
Weimar: Life on the Edge of Catastrophe
Tyler: “new and very interesting.”
From Katja Hoyer
Motherland
Julia Ioffe’s history of modern Russia through its women. Tyler “enjoyed it very much.”
From Julia Ioffe
Thomas More: A Life
Joanne Paul’s biography, which Tyler “very much enjoyed.”
From Joanne Paul
Second Act
Henry Oliver on late bloomers. Tyler: “a wonderful book.”
From Henry Oliver
The Last Dynasty
Toby Wilkinson on Ptolemaic Egypt. Tyler has “enjoyed reading all of your books.”
From Toby Wilkinson
Six Math Essentials
Terence Tao’s “new and excellent” book.
From Terence Tao
The Rise and Fall of Rational Control
Harvey Mansfield’s “new and excellent” book.
From Harvey Mansfield
The Time Tax
Annie Lowrey on the hours government takes from us. Also “new and excellent.”
From Annie Lowrey
The 99% Invisible City
Roman Mars and Kurt Kohlstedt’s field guide to everyday design. Tyler: “an excellent book.”
From Roman Mars
The Meaning of Your Life
Arthur Brooks’s “important new book.”
From Arthur Brooks
Profits, Prophets, Coaches, and Kings
Jared Diamond on when leaders matter. Tyler: “new and notable.”
From Jared Diamond
The One and the Ninety-Nine
From Luke Burgis, “one of my favorite current thinkers.”
From Luke Burgis
Kakistocracy
Richard Hanania’s book, which Tyler blurbed.
From Richard Hanania
Becoming a Principle-Driven Leader
By Charles and Chase Koch, which Tyler was “happy to blurb.”
From Chase Koch
Recommended on the show
Nostromo
Joseph Conrad’s novel is in Tyler’s “favorite 50, maybe even my favorite 30.” Richard Hanania paired it with Maya Jasanoff’s Conrad biography, The Dawn Watch, on Tyler’s recommendation.
From Richard Hanania
Bleak House and The Faerie Queene
Henry Oliver calls Bleak House “the best novel in English.” Tyler names the two as the most underrated great works.
From Henry Oliver
Democracy, by Henry Adams
A short Washington novel Henry Oliver recommends.
From Henry Oliver
Jonathan Swift beyond Gulliver
Henry Oliver’s reading list: a small selection of the poems, the Journal to Stella and the Drapier’s Letters.
From Henry Oliver
Speculations About Jakob
Uwe Johnson’s East German novel. Tyler: “That’s a great book.”
From Katja Hoyer
Anatomy of a Moment
Tyler likes Javier Cercas; Luis Garicano loves him and singles out this account of Spain’s 1981 coup attempt.
From Luis Garicano
Three underrated Russian books
Julia Ioffe’s picks: Guzel Yakhina’s Zuleikha, Svetlana Alexievich’s The Unwomanly Face of War and Nabokov’s Mary.
From Julia Ioffe
Neuromancer and the Slough House novels
William Gibson’s Neuromancer shaped how Craig Newmark saw the internet, and Mick Herron’s Jackson Lamb is now one of his role models. He’s also reading K. J. Parker.
From Craig Newmark
The Italians
Luigi Barzini’s 1960s portrait of the country. Luke Burgis: “just a fantastic book.”
From Luke Burgis
Mutiny on the Bounty
A Dave Baszucki favorite. He says the three film versions are “all good,” too.
From Dave Baszucki
Silent Spring
Jared Diamond ranks it with Darwin’s Origin of Species as the scientists’ books with the biggest impact of the last century.
From Jared Diamond
Leisure: The Basis of Culture
Josef Pieper’s book, which Arthur Brooks is reading as he plans his next chapter.
From Arthur Brooks
Music
Beggars Banquet and Let It Bleed
Bob Spitz’s picks for the best Rolling Stones albums. For the best song, Spitz says “19th Nervous Breakdown,” and Tyler: “That was my other pick.”
From Bob Spitz
Born to Run
Bob Spitz, who knew Springsteen early on, on “Thunder Road.”
From Bob Spitz
You Want It Darker
Leonard Cohen is Craig Newmark’s “rabbi,” and this is the album he keeps diving into.
From Craig Newmark
“Silent All These Years”
Tyler’s Tori Amos pick.
From Craig Newmark
Natalia Lafourcade and Julieta Venegas
Paul Gillingham’s picks for Mexican pop.
From Paul Gillingham
The Ligeti and Brahms horn trios
Arthur Brooks, a former professional horn player, would program Ligeti in the first half and Brahms in the second. Tyler: “I love it.”
From Arthur Brooks
Dennis Brain
Arthur Brooks’s greatest horn player ever, who made the first major recordings of the Mozart horn concertos and both Strauss concertos.
From Arthur Brooks
Monteverdi’s Vespers
Tyler’s other candidate, alongside the B Minor Mass.
From Luke Burgis
N.W.A
Part of Chase Koch’s musical education. Tyler: “It’s so good.”
From Chase Koch
Film and TV
Chimes at Midnight
Orson Welles’s Falstaff film, Tyler’s pick for the best Shakespeare movie.
From Henry Oliver
Tyler’s Bergman and Hitchcock
Smiles of a Summer Night, Scenes from a Marriage, Rear Window and Vertigo. More recently, Sirāt and The Drama.
From Craig Newmark
Slow Horses
Craig Newmark has adopted Jackson Lamb as a role model.
From Craig Newmark
The Pitt, Severance and For All Mankind
More of Craig Newmark’s long-form TV. He says K. J. Parker’s novels are “confidence porn, much like The Pitt is.”
From Craig Newmark
Three Mexican films
Silent Light, Y Tu Mamá También and The Three Burials of Melquiades Estrada.
From Paul Gillingham
Weimar cinema
Katja Hoyer on Metropolis and the films of the 1920s, plus Good Bye, Lenin!
From Katja Hoyer
Pluribus
Tyler and Henry Oliver were both watching it.
From Henry Oliver
Rafa
Chase Koch had just watched the Nadal documentary. Tyler: “it’s on my list.”
From Chase Koch
Kung Fu Hustle
Terence Tao’s favorite Hong Kong action movie; Tyler adds Drunken Master II.
From Terence Tao
Art
A Rembrandt print
Prices have risen, but Tyler notes a print is still within reach, and Andrew Graham-Dixon suggests a fifth state.
From Andrew Graham-Dixon
Antique textiles and quilts
Tyler calls textiles “grossly underpriced.” Graham-Dixon bought a Mennonite quilt.
From Andrew Graham-Dixon
Overlooked British women painters
Graham-Dixon knows a collector buying 1920s Royal Academy painters “for £5 each.”
From Andrew Graham-Dixon
Howard Hodgkin
Tyler still argues for him, and Graham-Dixon wrote a book on him.
From Andrew Graham-Dixon
Frank Auerbach and Otto Dix
Two of Michael Moritz’s artists, and two of Tyler’s.
From Michael Moritz
Holbein’s Thomas More at the Frick
Joanne Paul on Holbein’s portraits of More and Cromwell.
From Joanne Paul
Woman Holding a Balance
At the National Gallery of Art in Washington. Look for the nail.
From Andrew Graham-Dixon
George Stubbs’s zebra
Graham-Dixon’s favorite Stubbs, at the Yale Center for British Art.
From Andrew Graham-Dixon
Trips
Mexico beyond the capital
2 episodesTyler asked Paul Gillingham for the ideal two weeks in Mexico, skipping Mexico City and the ruins. This is his answer, about three days a stop, plus a detour Tyler would insist on.
- 1TijuanaStart by crossing the border from California.
- 2ZacatecasFly here for “the Baroque splendor of Mexico,” built on what was once the biggest mine in the world. Look for the Churrigueresque, where every inch is carved.
- 3AguascalientesGo during the annual feria for some of Mexico’s best bullfights, a rare week of legal gambling and a superb symphony orchestra.
- 4XalapaFly on to this city in Veracruz, “particularly untouristed for its quality,” with a beautiful temperate climate.
- 5Oaxaca and TlacolulaTyler’s detour: barbacoa in Tlacolula, 20 or 25 minutes outside the city, per his rule that the best meal is just outside town. Gillingham ranks Oaxacan cooking among Mexico’s best.
- 6San Cristóbal de las CasasEnd in the colonial capital of Chiapas.
For the flight: The Fifth Sun, one of the two Aztec histories Annie Lowrey just bought.
From Paul Gillingham and Annie Lowrey
The Roman Empire, edge to edge
2 episodesKim Bowes’s tour of the empire, with Tyler’s additions. Fly between stops.
- 1Hadrian’s Wall and VindolandaBowes starts at the northern frontier. Don’t miss Vindolanda’s Roman shoes.
- 2TrierOne of Tyler’s picks for Roman ruins.
- 3SegoviaThe Roman aqueduct, which Tyler recommends twice, with Bowes and with Joel Mokyr.
- 4PompeiiBowes’s tip: look for the stepping stones in the streets.
- 5SplitDiocletian’s Palace, Bowes’s pick.
- 6IstanbulEnd with the Roman waterworks Tyler points to with Mokyr.
Back home: the finds from Dura-Europos, the last stop on Bowes’s tour, are at Yale.
From Kim Bowes and Joel Mokyr
Italy’s less-discovered gems
4 episodesGenoa and Naples, the two cities Tyler and Luke Burgis agree are underrated, with stops from three other guests. Travel by train.
- 1VeniceRoman Mars’s advice: get lost in the alleys.
- 2GenoaBurgis’s pick for Italy’s most underrated city.
- 3FlorenceHarvey Mansfield spent a year here working on Machiavelli.
- 4PerugiaJoe Studwell lived nearby, in Central Italy.
- 5RomeMansfield’s other year of Machiavelli research.
- 6NaplesTyler’s second-favorite Italian city. “Maybe it’s my favorite.”
From Luke Burgis, Harvey Mansfield, Joe Studwell and Roman Mars
Spain off the usual route
3 episodesTyler calls Spain “one of my favorite countries to visit.” This route follows Luis Garicano to the corners he thinks visitors miss.
- 1MadridFly in.
- 2SegoviaAn hour away: the Roman aqueduct Tyler recommends in two episodes.
- 3AsturiasGaricano recorded his episode here and names it Spain’s special food region.
- 4CáceresIn Extremadura, which Garicano calls underrated: home of many conquistadors, “frozen in time,” with one of Spain’s best restaurants.
From Luis Garicano, Joel Mokyr and Kim Bowes
A pilgrim’s Europe
2 episodesEnglish churches with Diarmaid MacCulloch, then Cluny, the Camino and Rome with Luke Burgis. The soundtrack is Tyler’s: the B Minor Mass and Monteverdi’s Vespers.
- 1ElyIts cathedral is one of the English churches MacCulloch singles out.
- 2WetherdenThe Suffolk parish where MacCulloch grew up, at his father’s church.
- 3GloucesterAnother MacCulloch cathedral. Go for Evensong.
- 4ClunyBurgis: for 300 years the largest church in the world, and the abbey that first sent pilgrims down the Camino.
- 5Saint-Jean-Pied-de-PortThe traditional start of the Camino’s French route.
- 6Santiago de CompostelaWalk the Camino into Santiago.
- 7RomeBurgis’s way to show someone what he sees in the church: a beautiful Mass, “a lot of good wine” and conversation late into the night.
From Diarmaid MacCulloch and Luke Burgis
Britain beyond London
3 episodesFour stops from three guests, all reachable by train.
- 1LondonStart at the Barbican, Roman Mars’s pick.
- 2Warwick and KenilworthJoanne Paul’s favorite place in England: Warwick Castle, the Lord Leycester Hospital and Kenilworth nearby.
- 3LiverpoolBob Spitz lived here for a year and a half and found “the best Chinese food I’ve ever tasted,” plus interiors by the craftsmen who built the great ocean liners. Tyler: “I love Liverpool, actually.”
- 4EdinburghPaul’s other love: “I love Edinburgh.”
From Bob Spitz, Joanne Paul and Roman Mars
Food
Santo Taco, New York
Paul Gillingham’s downtown taqueria find.
From Paul Gillingham
San Francisco, per Brendan Foody
El Metate for everyday Mexican, Cotogna and Quince for something nicer. His general rule: check Beli.
From Brendan Foody
Oaxacan and Yucatecan cooking
Paul Gillingham calls them “head and shoulders above” the rest of Mexico’s cuisines.
From Paul Gillingham
The recipes of Apicius
Kim Bowes suggests cooking from the Roman cookbook, with the warning that it won’t taste like what we think of as good.
From Kim Bowes
Stocking stuffers
A better shower head
Craig Newmark’s real idea of luxury is good water pressure. Tyler: “I fully agree with you on that.”
From Craig Newmark
Flowers
Julia Ioffe on Russia’s flower culture. Tyler admits he never gets March 8 right.
From Julia Ioffe
Robux gift cards
For the Roblox player in your life. One Robux is “about a penny.”
From Dave Baszucki
A painted Mexican memento mori
Luke Burgis keeps a brightly painted skull from Mexico on his desk.
From Luke Burgis
Pomegranate juice
Tyler: “this is the podcast where we talk about the pomegranate juice industry.” Jared Diamond explains why it took Lynda Resnick 18 years to turn a profit.
From Jared Diamond
A Consensus subscription
Arthur Brooks’s AI search engine for academic papers: “the best research gopher I’ve ever had.”
From Arthur Brooks
Shopping links go to search results on Amazon, Etsy, JustWatch and Google Maps, plus a few museum sites. They aren’t affiliate links.